This Saturday, the East Tennessee State football team takes on Mercer (3 PM, ESPN+) looking to secure the Southern Conference’s automatic bid to the FCS playoffs.
Tyler Riddell was the starting quarterback the last time ETSU was in this spot. That was five years ago, and it’s been three seasons since Riddell’s time in Johnson City ended, but he still has warm memories of his time with the Bucs.
Even if his college career ended elsewhere.
“That [2021] season is one of the reasons I’m still able to kind of return to ETSU and be thought of being talked about a little bit still because of the season we had,” Riddell said when he spoke with I-81 Sports on Wednesday in an exclusive telephone interview. “And then gave me my only conference championship ring, which is something that I hold with me forever. Something I put up on the wall. You walk past it and just remember how good times were around that time. It’s kind of unexplainable, like, how much that that means to me.”
That 2021 campaign was one of the greatest by any ETSU signal caller. Riddell, a redshirt freshman, started all 13 games. He amassed 2,464 passing yards, completing 62.4% (211 of 338) of his throws with 19 touchdowns. He also ran for three more scores, and finished the season with a 139.25 QB rating.
As Buc fans know, Riddell did not play his entire career at ETSU. He transferred to Duquesne, where he played the 2024 and 2025 seasons, after an injury limited his 2023 campaign to three games.
It was actually the second time Riddell went into the portal during his time at ETSU. He entered the transfer portal after a 2022 season under George Quarles in which Riddell threw for 1,950 yards and 15 touchdowns.
“I regret entering the portal in the first place, the first time,” Riddell said. “I never wanted to be the guy that transferred because I loved ETSU so much and it meant so much to me.”
After returning to Johnson City, Riddell ironically had his 2023 season cut short by injury three games into the season. He went back into the portal after the Bucs hired Tre Lamb at the end of November in 2023. Riddell described Lamb as “an exceptional coach but just didn’t initially see me being a part of what he wanted to build and was forced into the portal from there.”
Riddell didn’t find a new home right away.
“During that spring semester I received a text from coach Lamb to come talk to him, come have lunch.”
Riddell decided not to accept the invitation.
“Whether that was right or wrong, I don’t know,” he said. “Just thought from that point, going forward, it’d be better to go somewhere else.”
Riddell landed at Gardner-Webb, coincidentally the program Lamb left to take the ETSU job after George Quarles was fired. He threw for 2,573 yards with a 134.18 passer rating, with 16 touchdowns. Riddell finished his college career at Duquesne as a graduate transfer, where, in 2025, he completed 167 of 295 passes – to the tune of 57% – for 2,053 yards and 26 touchdowns. The TD total ranked among the top 10 in the FCS that season.
Duquesne fit Riddell, so much so that he is currently an offensive analyst on the staff of Jerry Schmitt, the winningest active FCS head coach wrapping up his 22nd season leading the Dukes and his 33rd year on the staff. Offensive coordinator and quarterbacks coach Anthony Doria, Riddell’s position coach in 2025, is in his 16th season with Duquesne.
“I’m enjoying it. I love being a football coach,” Riddell said. “Like, this is literally what I get to do on a daily basis. You hear at least once a day how somebody hates their job. And I can’t say that. And then just, Duquesne in specific, the staff thought highly enough to keep me around, which I’m very appreciative of. And our staff here is just made up of a bunch of really good people who actually care about you.”
For all that Riddell has learned from Doria and Schmitt, his true sherpa in the coaching industry probably is Randy Sanders, Riddell’s head coach at ETSU. The former quarterback and offensive coordinator at Tennessee continues to be a guiding influence in Riddell’s career.
“In my eyes he’s Nick Saban. Like, he’s my Nick Saban,” Riddell said. “You never really know in the moment. … Like, when I was young, I just thought he was a hard ass. And in theory he was. But for good reasons, because he has seen everything. He has been through everything. I don’t think every coach that has coached me throughout my college career could put their knowledge together and have the amount of knowledge that he has about the game.”
Riddell said he and Sanders still talk frequently.
“We just had a 30 minute conversation yesterday,” Riddell said. “That guy’s just amazing. He’s the reason I know everything I know, which actually hurt me to an extent because I kind of refused to believe coaches after dealing with him. I didnt think they knew what he knew and I kinda found it hard to trust them.”
Riddell said he has been invited back to ETSU on multiple occasions. Given his obligations, first as a player and then as a coach, he hasn’t been able to return to Johnson City since he transferred out of the program after the 2023 season.
How would he like to be remembered by Bucs fans?
“I always kind of reconsider my career and think about it from time to time and really never played as well as I wanted to, honestly,” Riddell said. “I just hope everyone I came across could always say that I’m a good person, very caring, just simply just care about people. Like, I care about that place, I care about the university. I treat everybody I ever came across with respect. I don’t know. I wish I could be remembered as a better football player there. Not just kind of the one year. I wish I would have played better for multiple years, but in reality that’s just where I’m at. So I just hope everybody there has amazing things to say about me as a person.”