In a hard-fought Southeastern Conference opener at a sold-out Neyland Stadium that included a flyover and visit from President Donald Trump, No. 14/13 Tennessee fell just short against top-ranked Texas, 20-17.
Freshman quarterback Faizon Brandon threw a late 30-yard touchdown to Mike Matthews, the Vols recovered an onside kick, and the final Hail Mary was knocked away as time expired.
Tennessee’s defense was stout, limiting Texas to 61 rushing yards with 10 tackles for loss and six sacks but the offense managed just 221 total yards and zero rushing touchdowns.
Here is how the Volunteers graded out on General Robert Neyland’s seven game maxims.
1. The team that makes the fewest mistakes will win. (Grade: B-)
Tennessee won the turnover battle cleanly, finishing with zero giveaways while Texas committed two (including an interception by Kayin Lee). Brandon was careful with the ball (17-of-29, 145 yards, 1 TD, 0 INT). The Vols were the less-penalized team: getting seven flags for 55 yards versus Texas’ 11 for 115. Those advantages kept Tennessee in a one-score game against the nation’s No. 1 team. The mistakes that mattered most were the inability to convert enough third downs (4-of-16) and the offensive line’s protection issues that allowed Texas to rack up 10 sacks. Fewer self-inflicted wounds could have produced an upset.
2. Play for and make the breaks. When one comes your way…SCORE. (Grade: A-)
This was Tennessee’s strongest maxim. Qua Moss fielded a Mac Chiumento punt and raced 57 yards to the checkerboard for a touchdown that tied the game at 10 early in the third quarter, which was his first career score. Late, after Brandon’s 30-yard strike to Matthews made it 20-17 with 1:22 left, the Vols executed and recovered an onside kick at their own 49, giving themselves one final chance. Tennessee manufactured breaks and cashed in on the biggest ones. The only deduction here was that the final deep ball into the end zone was broken up instead of becoming the game-winning touchdown.
3. If at first the game or the breaks go against you, don’t let up … put on more steam. (Grade: A)
Texas scored on its opening drive, capping it with a 9-yard TD run by Raleek Brown, and led 10-3 at halftime. The Vols responded on Moss’ return. When Texas pushed the lead back to 20-10 on Brown’s second score with 5:41 remaining, Tennessee did not fold. Brandon directed a 10-play, 80-yard drive capped by the Matthews touchdown, then the special teams unit delivered the onside recovery. The defense, led by Arion Carter’s 11 tackles, Tyree Weathersby’s 2.5 sacks, and contributions from a host of others, was the definition of putting on more steam when the game tilted against them.
4. Protect our kickers, our QB, our lead and our ball game. (Grade: D)
This was the clear low point. Cooper Ranvier was perfect on his field goal and extra points, and the coverage units largely held up, but the offensive line failed to protect the quarterback. As mentioned, Texas recorded 10 sacks. Colin Simmons alone had five and Brandon finished with just 2 net rushing yards on 23 carries.
The Vols never had the lead and the inability to keep Brandon upright or sustain drives, especially in the second quarter when they were shut out, cost them the chance to control the game. Protecting the QB is non-negotiable under this maxim, and Tennessee fell well short.
5. Ball, oskie, cover, block, cut and slice, pursue and gang tackle … for this is the WINNING EDGE. (Grade: B+)
The defense more than embodied the “winning edge.” Carter’s 11 tackles set the tone. Weathersby’s 2.5 sacks, plus individual sacks from Amare Campbell, Xavier Gilliam, and Mariyon Dye, and a half-sack from Isaiah Campbell, produced six total sacks and 10 tackles for loss.
Texas was held to 61 rushing yards and 262 total. Moss added five stops and a pass break-up on defense while contributing on special teams. The Vols pursued, gang-tackled, and forced Texas into field goals more often than touchdowns. The offense’s lack of complementary blocking and the final incomplete pass prevented a full “A,” but the defensive effort was worthy of Neyland’s standard.
6. Press the kicking game. Here is where the breaks are made. (Grade: A)
Tennessee pressed and won the special teams battle that mattered most with the 57-yard punt return touchdown by Moss. The onside kick recovery with just over a minute left gave the Vols a realistic shot at the win. Ranvier was automatic and probably should have been given a chance to kick a field goal at the end of the first half. The Vols created the explosive plays in the kicking game that Neyland demanded. This maxim was executed at a high level.
7. Carry the fight to our opponent and keep it there for 60 minutes. (Grade: C)
The Vols’ defense did exactly that and never stopped bringing pressure. The late scoring drive and onside recovery showed fight until the final snap. But there were critical lulls from the offense particularly a scoreless second quarter and stretches where the offense could not sustain drives against Texas’ front. Possession time was nearly even (Tennessee had it for 31:23), but the inability to consistently move the ball — 70 rushing yards, and 4-of-16 on third downs — meant the fight was not fully carried for all 60 minutes. The effort was there — Brandon showed amazing heart for an 18 year old true freshman that fought through an injury and was constantly pressured — but the sustained offensive punch was not.
Overall: C+
Tennessee left Neyland with a moral victory in terms of effort and competitiveness against the top team in the country, but the final result was still a loss. The Vols excelled at creating and capitalizing on breaks (Maxims 2 and 6) and refused to quit (Maxim 3). Protection failures and limited offensive production were the difference. The Vols’ 2.9 yards per play is the fourth worst offensive output of the entire season in a game where both teams were from the FBS. That being said, if those areas improve, the same fight that nearly toppled No. 1 Texas will produce more wins in the weeks ahead.